Game on at Mount Florida bowling club
December 26 2019
Noah Developments are to follow up their delivery of six townhouses at Partickhill with proposals to build 40 flats and public open space at Mount Florida Bowling Club following its closure.
A design team comprising jmarchitects, RankinFraser and Blyth & Blyth has been brought on board with plans to create lower duplex apartments with flats stacked above in two blocks fronting Carmunnock Road behind an existing landscaped embankment, leaving a crescent of public open space to the rear.
In their design statement the architects observed: “Each building is designed ‘in the round’ with no clear hierarchy given to any one elevation due to the unique site context in which the buildings are located.
“Large fixed windows flood the internal spaces with light while slimmer opening windows are served by fixed glazed balustrades which function as a minimalistic protective barrier whilst the windows are in operation.”
Each block will be finished in weathered light grey/cream brick with deep vertical stack bond/soldier course bands and projecting balconies enlivening each elevation.
|
21 Comments
A cursory glance at the Design and Access statement responds, amongst other things, gives a flavour of the building typologies in the vicinity. Hardly a quaint conservation town or Disney’s Celebration...
Architecturally bland.
Deary me, some people with only a few words really give a flavour of the type of person they are...
Let’s be brutally honest here. The development as proposed is by no means shocking, regardless of the pompous commentary from the keyboard rambos.
Considering the architects, it can be said with a fair degree of certainty that the buildings in whatever final form they take will be well considered and detailed to a high level.
Suggest the statements are read and considered again son. If not, then jog on and take your negativity with you.
No amount of crisp detailing can mitigate the inappropriate strategy of urbanising the site in such a bombastic manor.
Are JM Architects so good they are above criticism?...mmmm
You have your bees in your bonnet regarding the design and that’s fine, but come on, get off your high horse and slap yourself with a sense of realism. This isn’t desecrating the ‘insert your masterpiece here’ - it’s proposing apartment blocks of a not too dissimilar scale from blocks in the immediate vicinity in order to meet a brief. In Glasgow... There are moves to set the design apart from the standard stuff we are seeing all over the shop - but the reality is it is nigh on impossible to produce anything of substantial / material difference in this city. Firstly because clients won’t allow it. Secondly because planners won’t allow it. Thirdly, because it will never live up to the standards of the great scholars who congregate on urban realm.
Answer: Yes.
Seems like a mssive waste of community greenspace too, since the 'greenspace' being offered here is to be maintained by residnets(!) rather than say, a community council of elected members.
Post your comments
Back to December 2019
Like us on Facebook
Become a fan and share